Are you tired of spending hours at the grocery store, only to come home and realize you’re not quite sure what to cook? That’s where meal kit delivery services come in. Dinnerly and EveryPlate are two popular options, but how do they stack up against each other? Let’s find out in this in-depth comparison.
Pricing and Value for Money
Let’s start with the all-important price factor. Dinnerly offers meals for 2 or 4 people with a choice of 2, 3, 4, 5, or 6 meals per week. Prices range from $5.49 per serving for the biggest box to $9.85 per serving for a box with 2 meals for 2 people. EveryPlate, on the other hand, serves 2, 4, or 6 people, and offers the choice of 3, 4, 5, or 6 meals per week. Prices range from $4.44 per serving for the biggest box to $11.67 per serving for a box with 3 meals for 2 people.
Let’s compare these two using our standard pricing measurement: 3 meals for 4 people, including delivery. Dinnerly comes in at $94.37, while EveryPlate is slightly cheaper at $89.99. If you’re strictly looking at price, EveryPlate is the winner. However, keep in mind that Dinnerly offers more meal options and a few extra features, which might make the slightly higher price worth it for some people.
Winner: EveryPlate
Menu Options and Health Ratings
When it comes to variety, Dinnerly definitely comes out on top. With 61 meals to choose from (including 10 “PLUS” meals that cost extra), you’ll never get bored of their menu. Dinnerly offers various types of recipes, including Fan Fave, Comfort Food, Kid-Approved, Reduced Carb, Balanced, 15-Min, and Feed a Crowd.
EveryPlate has a smaller selection, with 22 meals available to choose from (including 2 premium options). Although they have fewer choices, they focus on family-friendly meals, and you’re sure to find something you love. EveryPlate offers Kid Friendly, Speedy, and Veggie recipes. Health-wise, EveryPlate is not the best option, but it’s still decent for the price.
In terms of variety and health, Dinnerly is the winner here.
Winner: Dinnerly
Delivery and Packaging
Dinnerly delivers to Melbourne six days per week (Tuesday to Sunday), while EveryPlate delivers four days per week (Sunday to Wednesday). Both companies offer flat-rate shipping regardless of the size of the box ordered ($10.49 for Dinnerly and $9.99 for EveryPlate).
As for packaging, Dinnerly is generally more sustainable. They use recyclable packaging for their ice packs and cool storage, and they don’t print recipe cards. Instead, you’ll find interactive recipe cards on their app. This can be annoying for some people who like to multitask while cooking, but it’s a great way to save money and be eco-friendly.
EveryPlate’s packaging is also sustainable, but their items are loose in the box, which can lead to damaged produce and a bit more time spent organizing your ingredients. If you’re very time-poor, this could be a drawback for you. Dinnerly is the winner in this category.
Winner: Dinnerly
Customer Support
Both Dinnerly and EveryPlate have helpful and responsive customer support. While I’ve had to reach out to both companies for issues like ingredient quality or missing items, the overall experience has been positive. Dinnerly’s support team is particularly helpful when it comes to ingredient quality. EveryPlate, unfortunately, tended to have more issues come up with missing ingredients or damaged/low quality food.
Winner: Dinnerly
The Verdict
| Comparison Point | Dinnerly | EveryPlate | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing Range | $5.49-$9.85 | $4.44-$8.00 | EveryPlate |
| 3 Meals for 4 People | $94.37 | $89.99 | EveryPlate |
| Menu Range | 61 meals | 22 Meals | Dinnerly |
| Menu Type Variety | 7/10 - Several Options | 4/10 - Few Options - Most Basic | Dinnerly |
| Delivery Days | 6 Per Week | 4 Per Week | Dinnerly |
| Packaging Info | Loose in Box | Loose in Box | Tied |
| Quality of Ingredients | 6/10 - Occasionally damaged in transit. | 5/10 - Low quality at times. | Dinnerly |
| Customer Service | 8/10 | 6/10 | Dinnerly |
| Convenience | 5/10 - Good website but no recipe cards is a bit of a pain, and you do have to stay on top of pantry items. | 6/10 - Easy ordering, easy to follow instructions, some pantry items required. | EveryPlate |
| Overall Winner... | Dinnerly |
Dinnerly wins in terms of menu options, health ratings, delivery, and packaging. However, EveryPlate has a slight edge when it comes to pricing. If you’re looking for the absolute cheapest option, EveryPlate might be the one for you. But if you’re willing to spend a little more for a greater variety of meals, better packaging, and more delivery days, Dinnerly is the way to go.
In the end, it all comes down to your personal preferences and priorities. If you value a diverse menu and well-organized packaging, Dinnerly is the winner. But if you’re on a tight budget and don’t mind a smaller menu and loose items in the box, EveryPlate is a fantastic choice.
Whatever you choose, both Dinnerly and EveryPlate offer a convenient way to get delicious, home-cooked meals on the table without the hassle of grocery shopping and meal planning. So go ahead, give them a try, and see which one works best for you and your family.
Overall Winner: Dinnerly
